What is it?
A PICK Chart sorts ideas into four practical groups: Possible, Implement, Challenge and Kill. It uses impact and ease of delivery to help a team turn a collection of suggestions into an intentional action list.
What's it really for?
It gives permission to end ideas as well as start them. Improvement backlogs often grow because declining an idea feels harsher than leaving it permanently pending. The Kill quadrant is simply an honest decision that capacity can be used elsewhere.
You know when…
A workshop produces a wall of ideas and an excellent photograph. Three months later the photograph remains the most complete record of progress. Nobody chose which ideas would move, which needed testing and which could be released from captivity.
Have a go
- Define impact and ease for the decision at hand. ☐ Place each idea in Possible, Implement, Challenge or Kill. ☐ Discuss boundary cases and assumptions. ☐ Assign owners and dates to Implement items. ☐ Name the evidence needed for Possible and Challenge items. ☐ Close the Kill items clearly.
Why it works
The named quadrants make the consequence of placement harder to avoid. Ideas are not merely ranked; the team must decide whether to proceed, explore further, challenge the proposition or stop carrying it.
Look for…
Implement items with a genuine route to action, Possible ideas needing a small test, Challenge ideas whose benefit may justify redesign, and duplicate or outdated ideas ready to stop.
Watch out…
Do not use the labels as a verdict on the person who suggested the idea. Easy is not always wise, difficult is not always strategic, and ‘Kill’ should not become a parking area for politically awkward choices.
Worth noticing…
A clean Kill decision can create more progress than adding another green note to Implement.
Try next…
Use an Impact–Effort Matrix for gentler initial comparison. Use a Decision Matrix when several criteria must be balanced. Use A3 Thinking for a substantial Challenge item.